|
 |
 |
| Ballymun
- a summary introduction |
Introduction
Ballymun
is a public housing scheme that was built in the late sixties and
early seventies at a time when there were massive shortages in both
public and private housing in Dublin. As the only tower-block development ever undertaken by the
government of the Republic, Ballymun represents a once-off
experiment in building mass public housing in Ireland.
The
original vision for Ballymun was that it would be a state-of-the-art
and ultra-modern town within the city limits. Indeed, the Government's vision of Ballymun was as a flagship
project in the increasingly industrialised economy of Ireland and as
a symbol of Ireland's evolution into a modern European state.
The
original plans for this “new town” included the entire
infrastructure that a large town might feature - shops, cinemas,
leisure facilities, doctors clinics, and so on. In the event, the only shops that were built were in the
centrally located Shopping Centre, and it took a sustained campaign
by the local community to ensure that the promised swimming pool was
built (again in the Shopping Centre) almost ten years after the
housing phase was completed.
By
the mid-1970's, it was apparent that Ballymun was not living up to
the least of the expectations that the Government and the public may
have had. By the late
1990's, the Government had conceded that the great social housing
experiment in Ballymun had failed and that the problems associated
with this failure needed radical solutions.
|
 |
 |
| Community
and Voluntary Activity |
There
are a wide variety of community and voluntary groups in Ballymun
that have been established over the years by local people to tackle
the social and economic problems in the area. CAP currently has over 120 groups and individual community
workers on our mailing list
and these groups are working on
every area of concern to the community.
|
 |
 |
| The
Physical environment |
Ballymun
lies on the north of Dublin city and has the distinction of being
the largest high-rise public housing complex ever built in the south
of Ireland. The estate
consists of a mix of 2,814 flats in 4-, 8-, and 15- storey blocks
along with 2,400 houses concentrated in an area of 1.5 square miles.
A consistent
lack of investment in the maintenance and development of Ballymun
over 25 years led to serious degeneration of the physical environment. A
pilot project to refurbish one 15-storey and two 8-storey
blocks of flats was initiated in 1987 and completed in 1993. By 1996, on the basis of the evaluation of the pilot phase,
the decision had been taken to demolish the remaining flats and
build low-rise housing on-site.
|
 |
 |
| The
Regeneration of Ballymun |
The announcement of the decision to
demolish the flats was accompanied by promises to regenerate the
community as well as replace the housing stock. In 1997, Dublin Corporation established
Ballymun
Regeneration Limited to undertake the planning and
implementation of the regeneration programme.
The planned regeneration of Ballymun
offers the opportunity to rectify many mistakes made in the first
attempt and to learn from mistakes made in numerous other
“satellite towns” where large concentrations of public housing
without supporting infrastructure have led to the development of
sprawling ghettos of serious disadvantage.
|
 |
 |
| Current
Social Profile |
The
last 15 years have seen increasing investment of Government and
European resources in attempts to address the social and economic
problems in Ballymun. The current demographic profile of the population of the area
reveals why this kind of investment has been necessary and why it is
necessary to continue to increase investment over the foreseeable
future.
|
 |
 |
| Population |
The
population of Ballymun has been in decline since the start of the
1980s, a feature shared by many other older, more settled areas of
Dublin although the level of decline has been greater in Ballymun.
Between 1981
and 1991, the population was reduced by 22% to 17,045 people. Population
decline slowed between 1991 and 1996 when the
Census revealed 16,566 people living in the area, a decrease of 2.8%
on the 1991 figure. It is worth noting, however, that Ballymun Job Centre and the Ballymun
Partnership estimate that there is a “floating” population of
approximately 3,000 people living in Ballymun who do not show up in
Census figures. This suggests that there are approximately 19,500 people living in
Ballymun.
As noted by a 1997 Work Research
Centre (WRC) report on the social and economic status of Ballymun,
population decline can indicate significant social changes. It appears from the Census data that the most significant
social changes in Ballymun are the decrease in actual numbers of
young people between 1991 and 1996 and the increase in numbers of
lone parent families in the same period.
A detailed analysis of population
changes between 1991 and 1996 shows that every age cohort has
decreased over this period but there has been a particularly
noticeable decrease in the numbers of young adults and children
living in the area. This decline in numbers of young people suggests the out-movement of
two-parent families from Ballymun, which is supported by two other
statistics from the 1996 Census data.
|
 |
 |
| Gender
Profile |
Firstly,
there is a wide and untypical variation in the numbers of women as
compared to men in different age cohorts as outlined in the
following table. As can be seen from the following table, a normal gender
balance (i.e. about 50/50) in terms of numbers applies to the
population up to the age of 19.Within the age range 20 to 49, however, the gender profile is
such that in every five-year age cohort, the numbers of women
sharply exceed the numbers of men. This is particularly true of the cohort aged 25 to 29.
| Age |
Male |
Female |
Total |
| 0-4
years |
997 |
1012 |
2009 |
| 5-9
years |
930 |
890 |
1820 |
| 10-14
years |
850 |
724 |
1574 |
| 15-19
years |
830 |
847 |
1677 |
| 20-24
years |
795 |
970 |
1765 |
| 25-29
years |
690 |
1003 |
1693 |
| 30-39
years |
826 |
1064 |
1890 |
| 40-49
years |
709 |
859 |
1568 |
| 50-64
years |
1016 |
1047 |
2063 |
| 64
years + |
228 |
279 |
507 |
| Total |
7871 |
8695 |
16566 |
The second set of statistics that
illuminate the changing gender profile of Ballymun are those
revealing significant changes in household structure. Between
1991 and 1996, the total number of households increased from 4,828
to 5,044. Within this increase, there has been what the WRC
describe as a “substantial shift” in the types of households in
the area.
|
 |
 |
| Household
Structure |
In 1991, 42% of all households were made
up of couples with their children, including a small number with
other household members as well. At the same time, just over
28% of all households were headed by lone parents. In 1991,
this was an extremely high proportion of lone-parent households
compared to the national average and differentiated Ballymun from
many other areas of the country.
By 1996, the proportion of households
made up of couples with children had fallen to less than 35% while
lone-parent households had increased to just over 37% of all
households in Ballymun. This sharp increase in the number of
households headed by lone parents is illustrated in the following
table:
|
Household
Structure |
1996 |
% |
1991 |
% |
| Single,
no children |
829 |
16.4 |
804 |
16.7 |
| Couple,
no children |
389 |
7.7 |
360 |
7.5 |
| Couple
with children |
1564 |
31 |
1860 |
38.5 |
| Couple
with children + others |
186 |
3.7 |
168 |
3.5 |
| Lone
parents |
1634 |
32.4 |
1209 |
25.1 |
| Lone
parents + relative |
243 |
4.8 |
183 |
3.8 |
| Other |
199 |
3.9 |
241 |
5 |
| Total
# Households |
5044 |
|
4825 |
|
Households headed by lone parents
have now become the most prevalent household type in Ballymun.
When expressed as a proportion of households with children,
lone-parent households increased from 40.7% in 1991 to 51.7% -
a majority of households with children – in 1996.
The proportional
increase of lone-parent families in Ballymun in part reflects the
decrease in numbers of two-parent families living in the area.
However, there has also been an increase in the actual numbers of
lone-parent families living in Ballymun that may be the result of a
number of underlying factors suggested by the Census data:
There is a high
rate of single parenthood amongst young girls. The Census data provides no direct information on this
matter, but the number of women over the age of 15 who are single
increased from 2,636 to 3,006 between 1991 and 1996.
There is a high rate of marital
breakdown within Ballymun.Between
1991 and 1996 the number of women over the age of 15 who are
separated increased from 616 to 702. The number of widows also increased from 264 to 319.
The
pattern of uptake of Dublin Corporation housing in Ballymun is
higher amongst lone parents than amongst other categories (50% of
applications to Dublin Corporation for housing come from lone
parents).
A
breakdown of the age range of children living in one-parent families
strongly indicates a high level of young people, overwhelmingly
young women, with children:
| |
Mother
and Children Householders
|
Father
and Children Householders
|
| |
N.Units |
N.Children |
N.Units |
N.Children |
|
All
Children<15
|
1186 |
2254 |
36 |
63 |
|
All Children+15
|
337 |
571 |
85 |
135 |
|
Other
|
232 |
830 |
27 |
97 |
|
Total
|
1755 |
3655 |
146 |
295 |
As a result of the changes in
household structure in Ballymun, by 1996 over 46% of all children
were being reared in lone parent households, the vast majority of
which are headed by women:
| |
Number
of children |
%
of total children |
Average
number of children |
|
Couples |
4532 |
53.5 |
2.56 |
|
Lone
parents |
3950 |
46.5 |
2.07 |
|
Total
# children |
8482 |
100.0 |
|
|
 |
 |
| Labour
Force Participation |
The 1996 Census data shows the
population of Ballymun to be 11,973 people between the working age
of 15 and 64 years of age. Within this number, there are 5,497 males and 6,476
females. According to the Census data, 4,671 of these were at work,
362 were seeking their first job and 2,487 were unemployed. This is a total of 7,520 people participating in the labour
force, which represents a labour force participation rate of 62.8%.
Of the 7,520 people active in the
labour force, 2,849 were either unemployed or seeking their first job. This
represents an
unemployment rate of 37.9%.This
compares extremely poorly with both the official national figure of
8.7% or the Irish National Organisation of the Unemployed estimate
of 18% unemployment nationally. The rate for Ballymun would be slightly higher if calculated
for the public housing areas only – the above figures include a
number of privately owned housing estates that neighbour the flats
complex.
In any event, an unemployment rate of
37.9% is one of the highest in any community in the country and
almost five times the official national average for unemployment.
|
 |
 |
| Educational
Achievement |
There are currently approximately 2,350
pupils attending the 8 primary schools in Ballymun while
approximately 850 students are attending Ballymun Junior and Senior
Comprehensive schools. All of the children attending school in
Ballymun live in Ballymun, with the exception of children attending
the local Gaelscoil (i.e. a primary school that teaches through the
medium of Gaelic) which has pupils from outside the area.
Ongoing research
over the past decade points to a consistent pattern of problems for
the schools in Ballymun resulting in low educational attainment
among the young people attending local schools which is reflected in
the following comparative analysis of education participation rates
in 1991:
| |
%
leaving school at age 15 or less |
%
remaining in education at age 20 or over |
| Nationally |
36.1 |
8.2 |
| Dublin
City |
39.1 |
8.7 |
| Ballymun |
54.6 |
1.2 |
The WRC reports that early school
leaving patterns in Ballymun are consistently higher than national
or City averages and participation rates in higher education are
chronically low. A study of education and training among unemployed people in 1994
revealed the following comparison of educational attainment between
unemployed people in Ballymun and the rest of the country:
| |
Nationally |
Ballymun |
| %
of all unemployed with no qualifications |
46.7 |
56.3 |
| %
of young unemployed with no qualifications |
17.7 |
37.5 |
| %
of all unemployed with leaving certificate |
21.4 |
6.7 |
Local
research in 1996 estimated that less than 25% of children attending
schools in Ballymun complete the senior cycle. None of the Traveller children living in the area
(principally at St. Margaret’s Travellers site) attend the
secondary schools in the area. If they do undertake further education beyond primary level,
it is at one of two specialist training centres for Travellers
|
 |
 |
| Welfare
Dependency |
| The
WRC report of 1997 makes the point that the distinctive profile of
the population in Ballymun means that “labour force data and
unemployment statistics cannot provide a complete picture of the
extent to which people are excluded from participation in
employment”. For this reason, the WRC gathered together
information on welfare payments in general and on Dublin Corporation
tenancy status of Ballymun residents that they used to produce an
overall picture of welfare dependency in Ballymun in 1997.
Through this exercise, they concluded that:
The
extent of dependency on welfare from payments such as Lone Parents
Allowance, Disability Allowance, Training Allowances and so on is at
least equal to the level of dependency on payments from Unemployment
Assistance or Benefit. (Only those in receipt of Unemployment
Assistance or Benefit are counted for the purposes of the Live
Register or for the purpose of calculating the official unemployment
figures.)
The
scale of welfare dependency in Ballymun, particularly in the flats,
is revealed by two stark indicators:
71%
of Corporation households depend on social welfare as their only
source of income, and just
16% of Corporation tenants draw any income from employment.
|
 |
 |
| Drug
Dependency |
Absolute figures for the number of
people in Ballymun with addiction problems are not available. At present, the Eastern Health Board Satellite Clinic at
Domville House has 215 people on their methadone maintenance
programme. Of these, 28
people are aged 21 years or less. There are 120 people on the active waiting list for methadone
maintenance, 55 of whom are under 21 years of age. In addition, 35 local people are receiving methadone from the
mobile clinic which visits the area. The Health Board also report that 300 people have used the
needle exchange at Domville House or the mobile clinic since the
service came into operation in 1996.
Professional addiction counsellors
and Drugs Workers in the area estimate that there are between 350
and 400 intravenous drug users in the area who have not presented
for any kind of treatment. There is also serious concern among these workers and many other
professionals and volunteers working with young people about an
increasing number of young Ballymun people who are regularly smoking
heroin.
While there is no doubt that opiate
abuse is a significant and serious problem in Ballymun, alcohol
addiction is arguably a greater problem. Again, while there are no official statistics about alcohol
abuse in the area, it is the experience of local professionals and
volunteers that it plays a huge role in the difficulties experienced
by the most marginalised
families and young people.
|
 |
 |
| |
|
 |
 |
|
|